Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

 
©2009 *AngelRaye
:iconangelraye:

Artist's Comments

I am not too happy with this picture. So I would really like some pointers on this one to make it look better.
Comments preferred over faves.
Makoto Kino (c) Naoko Takuechi
Mikomi and Tama are mine.

Critiques


:icondigilee:
I am really enjoying this series. It is so cool too see you step outside of your comfort zone. I should definitely follow suite.

So I think this maybe the weakest Mother/Daughter drawing in the series. It is good, but the others you have done so far just seem to be on another level. And I think there maybe a few reasons for this.

1. The couch. I understand that drawing furniture is hard. Trust me, I just finished a class where I had to draw chairs, couches and all kinds of non-fun things. You’ve drawn the couch/chair actually pretty well. I just think the coloring on it is just too much. You have this one large solid color and it really draws your eye too it. I think the main problem is the color is not that flattering, and drowns out the girls in the image. Maybe had you done something a bit more pale, and added a few levels of shading, I know you have shading, but it hard to notice it. It also could use a few highlights, or just something to give it a texture that it is fabric and not a blotch of color.

2. The proportions of the girls seem a tad off. I think it is mostly Makoto, she just seems a tad short/small compared to the other two to give the impression that she is the mother. They are also sitting too high on the couch, making it look like they are floating a bit. They’re bottoms should be a bit lower then the line on the back of the couch, just too make it look like the are sitting more realistically (if that makes sense)

3. The colors of Mikomi and Tama’s dresses. It is just they are really-really bright green; it stands out a bit too much. Using a much more subtle green would help them stand out less and allow for the entire image to be enjoyed. It may just be my computer, but the green just stands out way too much and I don’t think I’ve seen many people wearing that shade of green. Then again, the green could be fine on everyone else’s computer and I am just crazy. :p

Now there is also a lot that works. I think you’ve drawn the girls really well, and the pose works, and is a nice touching moment. The coloring and shading is nice and I like that you are trying it more, it really helps things pop out. The background looks great and is nice and subtle and adds a nice balance to some of the colors.

I also really like that you've drawn the toes, it is nice and cute.
The Artist thought this was FAIR
5 out of 5 deviants thought this was fair.

Thank you for your Critique

You are not logged in.

Comments


love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconelysianneptune:
You did good on height variation. And I love Tama's red hair. Do you also draw the couches and things they sit on?
:iconiris-angel:
It's cute!^_^ Hm...I'm not sure really what to say. Try making the shadows darker and the highlights more visible. Try to add some shading to the couch too, not just to where they're sitting. I think other than that it looks great!

--
Commissions Open! Note me!:D

Avatar made by =TechnoPoptart--Thanks!:D
:iconrichforce:
they should smile more

--
Nobody tosses a dwarf! ~ Gimli, son of Gloin; Elf Friend

But your a great warrior and a swordsman, and your ten times bigger than I am stupid! ~ Willow Ulfgood
:iconemmystar:
I think you did a very good job on this one! Do more! :heart:

--
:sing: ""Cyberman, Cyberman, does whatever a Cyberman does"

WAHHH! I eat your socks!!
:iconsailor-serenity:
I think it looks great - i agree with *Iris-Angel though try making the shadows darker ^^

--
The story of life - Boy meets girl. Boy gets stupid. Boy and girl live stupidly ever after :giggle:

Icon by the lovely ~sawai159! :heart:
:iconvoltronz1:
Amazing, simply amazing. But I have to agree with the others, you should try a little more. But anyway, great work my dear Robin. Once again, here is a theme for the three. [link]

--
Trooper Transform! We Are VR!
I believe in Jesus Christ my Saviour. If you do too, copy and paste this into your signature.
:icondidi-esmeralda:
good job

--
Visit my Gallery
:D[link]:D



¨Las Ideas son Capitales, entre las Manos del Talento¨

Didi Esmeralda
:iconangelraye:
Thank you and yes :D

--
I believe in Jesus Christ my Saviour. If you do too, copy and paste this into your signature :pray:
:iconangelraye:
Thank you and thanks for the tips :)

--
I believe in Jesus Christ my Saviour. If you do too, copy and paste this into your signature :pray:

Details

June 23
758 KB
101 KB
600×644

Statistics

23
24 [who?]
283 (0 today)
0 (0 today)

Camera Data

HP
HP Scanjet G3110
Jun 22, 2009, 6:48:46 PM

Share

Link
Embed
Thumb

Site Map